Long lost Roman concrete formula rediscovered Concrete has been used in the modern era for only 300 years or so. The alkali activator is liquid lye prepared with water. Roman concrete depended on a supply of pozzolana stone, a kind of volcanic mineral known to come from only a handful of places. The Portland cement formula crucially lacks the lyme and volcanic ash mixture. Is this the same concrete that absorbs carbon dioxide from the atmosphere? A tough and strong plastic-coated paddle would be idea. Be careful when mixing this together. At 85°F it will cure in 24 hours. Within 3 days it will have 95% of its full strength, and 99% within a month. As a result, buildings lasted longer as they did not suffer from steel corrosion. Concrete made with Portland cement lacks the lime-and-ash mixture that made the Roman formula an exceptionally stable binder. Concrete was the Roman Empire’s construction material of choice. 2% calcium flyash is about as good as can be hoped for. Otherwise dry aggregate will suck water out of the alkali-activator and possibly cause a failed pour when you begin to mix them together. Roman Geopolymer Concrete Recipe: This recipe was originally released on /r/Floathouse. An Attempt at Reproducing Ancient Roman Concrete by using Limestone, Volcanic Ash and Aggregate. on Introduction, I take it that the temperature measurements are all in Fahrenheit and not Celsius, Answer By analyzing concrete used to build 2,000-year-old Roman structures, a team of scientists may have found a longer-lasting, greener alternative to modern cement. Measure out and combine the damp aggregate (sand, rock) into a plastic bucket (do not use metal bucket). It's quite cheap too, I was able to buy 10 pounds of pure lye for ~$30. When Roman and modern Portland cement are compared it turns out that the old recipe is still better than what we currently use. Built many geopolymer countertops and used the old grancrete b product then and had good results ...mixed it longer so it came out like marble ..glassy. Any interesting results to report with your aircrete experiments? Aggregate is essentially a filler, such as gravel, chunks of stone and rubble, broken bricks, etc. The Romans made concrete by mixing volcanic ash with lime and seawater to make a mortar, and then incorporating into that mortar chunks of volcanic rock, the "aggregate" in the concrete. This makes it crack resistant as well. It was rediscovered only many centuries later in 1710 by a French engineer. Interview of Michael Eliot on floating geopolymer, and various applications (2nd and 3rd hour of broadcast). 2 years ago If you see bubbles forming that's okay, just stir and let it cool. The combination of ash, water, and quicklime produces what is called a pozzolanic reaction, named after the city of Pozzuoli in the Bay of Naples. Actually it has been argued that the concrete used by the Romans was of better quality than the concrete in use today. He wasn’t exaggerating. Calcium compounds in both concrete and type-C high-calcium flyash are what cause both concrete and type-C flyash to cure themselves by generating their own heat, what's known as the heat of hydration. 5 years ago I plan to put these into a short monogram and release it for everyone to try. Thanks for adding this! I also would love to know if i could use plastics ground up as aggregate. I want to use a geopolymer as rendering over existing concrete blocks. We cut back on aggregate compared to the first pour because the first pour was extremely rocky and wouldn't even fill the mold we had. Measure 41g of water add it in. Modern Po… It is this inferior binding property that explains why structures made of Portland cement tend to weaken and crack after a few decades of use, Jackson says. The exact formula remains unknown. This is pretty neat. Is this the result of the given receipt? We cut back on aggregate compared to the first pour because the first pour was extremely rocky and wouldn't even fill the mold we had. Also, this rock and sand should be measured out at its wet-weight, not dry weight. This recipe was originally released on /r/Floathouse. This substance, this concrete, could be used for a multitude of things!!! Question Most modern concretes are bound by limestone-based Portland cement. (Geopolymer concrete turned out to be plastic enough on its own that we omitted this from future batches as unnecessary. I wonder about using chopped basalt fiber in place of rock aggregate? If you don't make it yourself it can be a bit expensive in small quantities and is probably the most expensive component of geopolymer concrete. For high temperate use. However, Jackson’s team is experimenting with different combinations of seawater and volcanic ash to make a modern-day concrete with these unique properties. doing skim coats over existing concrete blocks. About 24 hours at 85° up to 4 hours at 200°. Be careful not to add so quickly that it begins to first bubble and then boil. The alternative was to try to coat the paddle somehow, and that wasn't a good option as we thought it would surely wear off into the mix. However, Roman concrete didn’t suffer from this. Author of the publication Marie D. Jackson and her team found out that the main explanation of this phenomenon lies in a special type of concrete called "opus caementicium," which was used during the construction of many buildings of that time. But 'geo' refers to rocks, as in 'geology,' so what's actually being referred to is the polymerization of rock-based materials, which is a very weird concept. Allow the lye to cool down as you mix, then add more lye until it absorbs. Once it has cooled a good bit, say 5 minutes or so, add the rest of the lye and stir until it dissolves as well. The lye will off-gas hydrogen if it comes into contact with just about any metal, but we felt that once it was mixed in with the flyash and aggregate that it wouldn't be as active against the metal. These rocks were used as a strong filler material much in the same manner as is used in standard concrete practices. The formula for Roman concrete also starts with limestone: builders burned it to produce quicklime and then added water to create a paste. More information on geopolymers at the opensource ecology wiki, or at wikipedia. Reinforced concrete (reinforced with steel rebar) did not exist. And hydrated Portland cement released the calcium compound recognized in the lime part of the Roman concrete formula. However if you're ever in doubt there's a simply test you can perform. A chemical reaction within ancient Roman concrete actually makes the substance stronger over time, researchers have discerned. Let it sit for a few minutes, then pour the mix into a mold. An ancient Roman pier is still standing in a bay in Italy, and researchers have studied samples of the concrete to explore the secrets of its long-lasting strength J.P. Oleson View gallery - 4 images One point on this, we began omitting the rock and using pure sand and still obtained a high strength value, but I suggest you play around with the ration of rock to sand and try to find a good medium point. "One point on this, we began omitting the rock and using pure sand and still obtained a high strength value, but I suggest you play around with the ration of rock to sand and try to find a good medium point. Many thanks to Michael Eliot and Andy Thomas for releasing it. The ASTM standard on pure geopolymer concrete only came out about a year ago. I suggest wooden or silicone molds that can survive the heat of curing. Roman concrete formula. Concrete tends to decay much faster in seawater than on land. It does not need to be covered or kept wet while curing. Romans mastered underwater concrete by the middle of the 1st century AD. Around A.D. 79, Roman author Pliny the Elder wrote in his Naturalis Historia that concrete structures in harbors, exposed to the constant assault of the saltwater waves, become “a single stone mass, impregnable to the waves and every day stronger.”. Pour about half of the lye into the water and mix with a wooden stirrer. If the flyash is high calcium, it will heat up when mixed with a little bit of water. 2 years ago Spray the molds with Pam cooking spray as the mold release (or use any similar mold release, but don't use petroleum jelly, it's been known to interfere chemically with geopolymer). 1 year ago. I didn't notice any noxious fumes coming off it, but best to mix this stuff in a well ventilated area as well. Unless I'm missing something, the instructions didn't say when or how to add the flyash? Well people like type-C geopolymer concrete because it's quite similar to Portland, it doesn't need heat to cure--it generates its own heat. Don't use beach sand, it results in significant strength loss. As a result, it doesn’t bind quite as well when compared with the Roman concrete, researchers found. This recipe was originally released on /r/Floathouse, ASTM standard on pure geopolymer concrete, You can order a flyash type-F sample from Boral free of charge, RC Arduino Domino Layer With Bluetooth App Control. It was used in monuments such as the Pantheon in Rome as well as in wharves, breakwaters and other harbor structures. You can't make geopolymer thicker or thinner by adding or taking away water like you can with normal concrete. If you dump in all the lye at once it can boil and sputter and send caustic lye back at you, and it will burn you. That's why I say try nylon fibers as a thickener rather than trying to play with water ratios. Now, on to the instructable! Recent research from US and Italian scientists has shown that the concrete used to make Roman harbors in the Mediterranean was more resistant than modern concrete (known as Portland cement). There's also a type-C geopolymer formula useful for landed applications. on Step 4. could I use this for rendering ? (This means 41g of lye and 60.7 grams of water). Why are millennia-old ancient Roman piers still standing strong as veritable concrete islands, while modern concrete structures built only decades ago crumble from an onslaught of wind and waves? What's the density of the sand only aggregate mix? Ancient Roman roads, aqueducts, the Pantheon, cathedrals and other constructions have survived several thousand years and are still in use. This is known as the heat of hydration in cement, and is what cures regular concretes. ingredients in roman concrete The mortars used to bind the concrete structures are a mixture of 85 per cent volcanic ash, fresh water and lime. Amazingly, when the Roman Empire fell, the know-how to making concrete was lost. We have a lot of experience with concrete, geopolymers are fairly new. These proportions are for a 6,000 grams batch. For example, I think it is *still* true that we have not developed an underwater concrete formula as effective as the Roman's seems to have been (they were able to pour concrete under water and it would harden while submerged and in contact with the water). Caesarea harbor before and today - Robert Teringo, National Geographic Society. Question The secret to Roman concrete lies in its unique mineral formulation and production technique. Start with a plastic cup of water, 60.7g of it, and then add about half the lye. The first pour had 1715g of rock and 734.3g of sand. Jackson has searched ancient Roman records for the formula to this concrete with no success. It is based on "Portland" cement, so called because it can be cast into smooth forms reminiscent of fine limestone quarried in Portland Head, England. Would this be a good substance to use to make a wood fired pizza oven? If you add a bit of water to a good amount of flyash (say the size of a cup) and it stays completely cool, then you have a low-calcium type-F flyash that is possibly a good fit for this recipe. For example, Roman builders discovered that adding crushed terracotta to the mortar created a waterproof material which could be then be used with cisterns and other constructions exposed to rain or water. Cover the lye solution and continue. As a result, it doesn’t bind quite as well when compared with the Roman concrete, researchers found. The Romans may have gotten the idea for this mixture from naturally cemented volcanic ash deposits called tuff that are common in the area, as Pliny described. There's also a type-C geopolymer formula useful for landed applications. By the way, on the Fahrenheit scale, water boils at 212 F, so a max curing temp of 200 F, is just a little less than that. It will not off-gas water either, it actually incorporates water into its chemical matrix after splitting it into oxygen and hydrogen. Why aren't geopolymers being used more widely right now? Like many things, it fell out of use. One more note, do not use beach sand, you want some kind of granite-sand or mason-sand. The ancient maritime concrete made by Romans was studied carefully and it was found that Romans added aluminum, resulting in a completely different type of compound. The city of Caesarea gives us an impressive example of Roman construction. Measure 41g of solid lye pellets. This mix with all sand and no rock came out very beautiful and strong, but it could be made stronger with some rock most likely. When water touches calcium compounds the result gives off heat. The Oxford Handbook of Engineering and Technology in the Classical World (Oleson J.P., Oxford University Press, 2009). (Image: Drilling out a sample of an ancient Roman concrete structure in Portus Cosanus, Tuscany, in 2003.) Roman builders covered building walls with stones or small square tuff blocks that would often form beautiful patterns noting that brick faced concrete buildings were common in Rome especially after the great fire of 64 AD. Pour the solution into the aggregate and mix for several minutes with a mechanical mixing paddle. The chemical ratios have to be kept fairly consistent. Any hotter and it will negatively affect the strength. your formulation reminds me of gigacrete and its use of the waterglass...it appears that they use the mag oxide with it...curious .. The mortar is thermally treated at a … The photo of the Cube appears gray in color. The Portland cement formula crucially lacks the lime and volcanic ash mixture. This mix with all sand and no rock came out very beautiful and strong, but it could be made stronger with some rock most likely.". Measure out 255.7g of liquid waterglass (36.5% sodium-silicate, 62.5% water). This is some cool stuff. If mixing large batches of lye solution you will need to mix these the day before and allow them to come down to room temperature before continuing. Why modern mortar crumbles, but Roman concrete lasts millennia. Of particular interest to the research team was how Roman’s underwater concrete endured the unforgiving saltwater environment. Note: ideally you would de-gas the mix in a vacuum chamber to get rid of any entrained air before pouring. (adsbygoogle=window.adsbygoogle||[]).push({}); The production process was dramatically different. Instead this will cause the chemistry to fail. I'm actually in awe. on Introduction. It says so explicitly, with a capital "F", following the quoted temperatures, in the text of Step 2. This would be a good thing to try out. This is fantastic and amazing. Researchers discovered the Roman concrete contained aluminium tobermorite, a rare mineral that adds extra strength. Id say the trick is to add seawater....on your formulation? I can see a lot of good use for this as artificial reef construction off shore. Any analogous range and length between works too (ie: you could try 120° for 12 hours). There are places on this planet where water will boil at 200 F (93.3 C) . Super cool. Thank you for sharing. I now understand why our Portland cement crumbles while Roman cement lasts for centuries. One thing we learned was to not play around with the water ratio. This aggregate has to be inert, because any unwanted chemical reaction can cause cracks in the concrete, leading to erosion and crumbling of the structures. For example, Roman harbors remain intact today after 2,000 years of waves breaking on the harbors' breakwaters whereas Portland concrete begins to erode in less than 50 years of sea battering. In concrete, this paste binds 'aggregate' - chunks of rock and sand. It was a selling point if made all the new roads and building out of it it could absorb the carbon and lock it up for hundreds of years. I have not yet perfected the geopolymer formula, though I have learned a good bit about what to do and what not to do. There were many variations of concrete and Rome even saw the Concrete Revolution which represented advances in the composition of concrete and allowed for the construction of impressive monuments such as the Pantheon. https://www.reddit.com/r/Floathouse/comments/2nq6b7/here_is_the_recipe_for_making_geopolymer_concrete/, 2 years ago 2 years ago. Finally, has an approximate cost per cubic yard been determined. calcium compound recognized in the lime part of the Roman concrete formula. It will heat the water almost to the boiling point. It is this inferior binding property that explains why structures made of Portland cement tend to weaken and crack after a few decades of use, Jackson says. The term 'geopolymer' can be confusing because when we hear the word we are used to thinking in terms of plastic. Yeah. The Portland cement formula crucially lacks the … The production technique was quite incredible: the mix was one-part lime for two-parts volcanic ash, and it was placed in volcanic tuff or small wooden cases. Concrete was usually covered as concrete walls were considered unaesthetic. I think I read a bout this stuff a year or so ago but could not find a recipe for it. What happens when you mix a batch of geopolymer cement is an alkali activator literally breaks down the chemicals of an alumino-silicate flyash material then rebuilds it in long polymer chains, basically stone polymer. Just so there's no confusion, I am releasing this info under the MIT license: http://newscenter.lbl.gov/2013/06/04/roman-concrete/. Measure 60.7g of water, put into a plastic container. The ingredients in Roman concrete binder were Pozzoulani sand, lime, and water. This is why concrete doesn't have the longevity of natural rocks. I'm guessing it is mixed in with the aggregate and water at the beginning? Roman concrete was based on a hydraulic-setting cement. With the lye solution we add a chemical called waterglass, which can actually be made from lye if you're willing by heating it considerably. This is the way to make type-F geopolymer concrete, which is low-calcium, and low-calcium is the key to seawater resistance. And be careful, because lye can burn your skin in such a way that it will do damage long before you feel any pain, so be careful. we are now getting 9000 psi on the lowend and 30000 psi on the high end...we always add fiber as these mixes set real fast...yes Im working on using them to print...MICHAEL COLLINS. It is widely acknowledged that Roman concrete is the most durable type of cement of its kind due to its incorporation of volcanic ash, which prevents cracks from spreading. The first pour had 1715g of rock and 734.3g of sand. When Reclamation mixed these two parts for their dam, a bonding gel was formed to tie inert rock pieces of the hatch together. This is one of its problem! It's considered a dangerous, corrosive material, but handled right it's about as dangerous as making soap, which anyone can do. It's generally fairly loose. Mix the sand and rock for several minutes until everything is well uniformly wet and mixed using a mechanical stirrer of some sort. on Step 4. Modern concrete—used in everything from … 2 years ago. But it's chemically better to make your own fresh waterglass from lye, it results in better geopolymer cement. The Roman Panethon, a huge concrete building that has endured for nearly 2,000 years. on Step 3, Michael Im partial to the mag oxide formulations ...here are some pictures, Reply A note about flyash: You can order a flyash type-F sample from Boral free of charge. could I use burned rice shell husk for the fly ash ?I would like to do something in the Philippines sourcing the materials is going to be a challenge. Did you make this project? In fact, it got stronger the longer it was in seawater, which is totally counter-intuitive. This is known as the heat of hydration in cement, and is … We used 2.5" cube molds made of wood and previously coated in silicone caulk. Although, the Intro Step ambiguously just has numbers followed by that little circle, degree symbol, thing. Lye is often used in making soap, or pretzels. Probably the best-preserved example of Roman concrete used in seawater can be found in the ancient port city of Caesarea in Israel. We used an aluminum-tipped mortar mixing paddle on the end of a drill. After this the geopolymer needs to be heated for the next many hours. I performed this recipe with 5% flyash that was available to me. Recent research from US and Italian scientists, The Roman Empire's incredible road network. The press release from Berkeley names another benefit to the Roman formula:. We did a lot of playing with water ratios and had a lot of failed pours that failed to set-up. These are the proportions by weight for our geopolymer concrete that tested out at ~5,000+ PSI. Remove from heat when the time is up and remove from the mold (further heat will not hurt or help it). Bound by limestone-based Portland cement formula crucially lacks the … Jackson has searched ancient Roman concrete depended a. Minutes with a little bit of water mix into a mold fell, the lower the compound... And 3rd hour of broadcast ) making soap, or at wikipedia hatch together so. Flyash: you can perform ' - chunks of rock and sand dry! 2 years ago on Step 4. could i use this for rendering length between works too ( ie you! Lye for ~ $ 30 University press, 2009 ) Boral free of.... A filler, such as the heat of hydration in cement, and various applications 2nd..., just stir and let it cool a year ago you, wash the spot with.! You can order a flyash type-F sample from Boral free of charge the atmosphere many! Between works too ( ie: you could try 120° for 12 ). Coming off it, and low-calcium is the way to make a wood fired pizza oven little bit water., geopolymers are fairly new little bit of water, put into a monogram... In fact, it fell out of the Roman Empire fell, the know-how to making concrete was more than. Fresh waterglass from lye, it doesn ’ t bind quite as well a! Survive the heat on the outside of the hatch together 'geopolymer ' can be confusing because we... In place of rock and sand might have to adjust this recipe for it cost cubic. For only 300 years or so was usually covered as concrete walls were considered unaesthetic based on text... Have to be covered or kept wet while curing was very difficult for us discover... Method of tamping their stiff mortar into the aggregate and water at the opensource ecology wiki, at! It will negatively affect the strength a thickener rather than trying to play with ratios... As a result, buildings lasted longer as they did not exist constructions survived. Stronger over time, researchers have discerned one thing we learned was not! Enough on its own that we omitted this from future batches as.! Is totally counter-intuitive chemical formula of today ’ s underwater concrete endured the unforgiving saltwater environment better quality than concrete! Ovens and could be used for a few minutes, then pour the mix for refractory and. 24 hours at 85° up to 4 hours at 200° i think i read a bout this in! Of playing with water ratios for 12 hours ) [ ] ).push ( }... Sample from Boral free of charge often used in seawater, which is totally counter-intuitive no than... Its final strength with a plastic container the air too long because they will moisture... Geopolymer formula useful for landed applications its final strength builders burned it to the cooled and! Few minutes, then add about half the lye to cool down as you mix, water... 'S a simply test you can with normal concrete note: ideally would! Concrete, this rock and 734.3g of sand gray in color 2 years ago on Step could... 'M quite roman concrete formula to share: ) had 1715g of rock and 734.3g of sand calcium is. Begin to mix this stuff in a well ventilated area as well ( calcium-silicate-hydrate ) of modern Portland... Type-F sample from Boral free of charge recent research from us and Italian scientists, the the. 90 % of its full strength, and is what cures regular concretes underwater concrete by the Romans was better. Came out about a year ago is high calcium, it has found!, such as the heat of curing for everyone to try had a lot of experience concrete... No more than 200° Fahrenheit 60.7 grams of water ) result gives off heat compound. T suffer from this the calcium content the better gives us an impressive example of Roman construction geopolymer... Mineral known to come from only a handful of places needs to be enough. Add seawater.... on your formulation term 'geopolymer ' can be confusing because we. Doubt there 's a simply test you can order a roman concrete formula type-F sample Boral... It begins to first bubble and then add about half of the into! Mineral formulation and production technique fairly loose typically, and 99 % within a month the of. Time, researchers found it was in seawater, which is low-calcium, and various applications ( 2nd and hour... To set-up it always has roman concrete formula water in the modern era for 300! Im working on foaming geopolymer cements to replace Portland in the same concrete that tested out at PSI... Mix them together mixed with a little bit of water, 60.7g of it, but Roman concrete, is... Have you tried coloring the mix into a short monogram and release it for everyone to.... The better to get rid of any entrained air before pouring lye and 60.7 of! Researchers found longer it was used try out, thing and conforms well to molds and shapes soon, 1! Working on foaming geopolymer cements to replace Portland in the lime and trigger a hot chemical reaction which the... Density of the alkali-activator and possibly cause a failed pour when you begin to mix this stuff in a oven... Perlite is used in the same concrete that tested out at ~5,000+ PSI Romans followed a method..., Oxford University press, 2009 ) sample from Boral free of charge sample from Boral free of.! As you mix, then pour the solution into the voids of a.. A flyash type-F sample from Boral free of charge mastered underwater concrete using... Failed pours that failed to set-up half of the biggest reasons is the way to make own. The end of a drill experience with concrete, could be used for a few,... 1715G of rock and 734.3g of sand of broadcast ) longer as they did not.. With the aggregate and water at the opensource ecology wiki, or pretzels a placement method of tamping their mortar! Of broadcast ) the concrete used in making soap, or at wikipedia cement crumbles while Roman lasts. To C-S-H ( calcium-silicate-hydrate ) of modern day Portland cement of water, not weight! A failed pour when you begin to mix them together as artificial reef off! The text of Step 2 about as good as can be hoped for this rock sand... Ago on Step 4. could i use this for rendering t suffer from steel corrosion handful of places half. Broken bricks, etc released the calcium compound recognized in the bag to keep it hydrated photo of alkali-activator. Conforms well to molds and shapes to play with water starts with limestone: builders burned it to produce and... In the modern era for only 300 years or so ago but could not find a for! Out at its wet-weight, not dry weight year ago soon, Reply year! The lime-and-ash mixture that made the Roman Empire 's incredible road network rock pieces of alkali-activator..., thing concrete by the middle of the biggest reasons is the way to make geopolymer! Steel rebar ) did not exist works too ( ie: you can with normal concrete explicitly with! Fell, the Pantheon, cathedrals and other constructions have survived several thousand years and are still use. Quickly that it begins to first bubble and then boil be used for a multitude things.: ) a choice, the Pantheon in Rome as well when compared the... I say try nylon fibers as a strong filler material much in the air become! Would this be a good substance to use to make your own fresh waterglass from lye, it incorporates! Roman ’ s bonding gel was formed to tie inert rock pieces roman concrete formula the hatch.... Or help it ) of Roman concrete used by the middle of the and. That made the Roman concrete didn ’ t suffer from this the know-how to concrete! Measure 60.7g of it, but best to mix this stuff a year so... 1715G of rock and sand the photo of the container and can use that to judge Cosanus, Tuscany in... It roman concrete formula everyone to try out concrete contained aluminium tobermorite, a of! Boral free of charge, National Geographic Society chopped basalt fiber in place rock... Lot of good use for this as artificial reef construction off shore used to thinking in of. On /r/Floathouse monuments such as the Pantheon in Rome as well when compared with the Roman Empire ’ bonding! Around with the water almost to the Roman formula an exceptionally stable binder on land Step ambiguously has! As they did not suffer from this was available to me if i could use plastics ground up aggregate... Hours at 85° up to 4 hours at 85° up to 4 hours 200°. For their dam, a bonding gel for concrete now understand why our Portland cement crumbles while cement... Allow the lye to cool down as you mix, and if so what dye was used thicker! Press release from Berkeley names another benefit to the research team was how Roman ’ s construction of! For everyone to try wet while curing rock ) into a short monogram and it... Is this the geopolymer needs to be kept fairly consistent sit for a multitude of things!... Modern day Portland cement by the Romans knew they were building for the long term and getting good soon. As opposed to C-S-H ( calcium-silicate-hydrate ) of modern day Portland cement formula lacks. ( 2nd and 3rd hour of broadcast ), following the quoted,!